Compare suburbs / Carlisle vs St James

Carlisle vs St James

Two neighbouring Perth suburbs side by side, from official WA Police, ABS, DFES and Transperth data. Each figure is the one shown on the suburb's own page.

Quick answers

Is Carlisle or St James safer?
Carlisle has the lower recorded crime rate in FY 2024-25: 130 offences per 1,000 residents, against 191 in St James (WA Police).
Is Carlisle or St James cheaper to rent?
Median weekly rents were about the same at the 2021 Census: $340 in Carlisle and $330 in St James (ABS).
Which is more advantaged, Carlisle or St James?
Carlisle has the higher SEIFA advantage decile: 6.2 out of 10, against 6.1 for St James (ABS SEIFA 2021).
Does Carlisle or St James have a train station?
Carlisle has no train station; St James has no train station (Transperth GTFS).
CarlisleSt James
Population
ABS 2021 Census
6,7334,894
Median age
ABS 2021 Census
3632
Median household income
ABS 2021 Census
$1,766/wk$1,827/wk
Median rent
ABS 2021 Census
$340/wk$330/wk
SEIFA advantage
ABS SEIFA 2021
6.2/106.1/10
Crime rate
WA Police FY 2024-25, per 1,000 residents
130 / 1,000191 / 1,000
Bushfire prone
DFES bush fire prone areas
0% of area0% of area
Train stations
Transperth GTFS
00
Bus/ferry stops
Transperth GTFS
3924
NBN fibre (FTTP)
infrastructure.gov.au, July 2020
99% of area65% of area

Green marks the lower crime rate, rent and bushfire share, and the higher SEIFA, transport and fibre figures. It is not a verdict on which suburb is better. Informational only.

Look closer

Choosing between Carlisle and St James?

We'll email you the full Carlisle profile, with a link to its page. Free, no spam.

How Keys stores and uses your email

More neighbour comparisons